Covering Annandale, Bailey's Crossroads, Lincolnia, and Seven Corners in Fairfax County, Virginia

Fairfax County staff recommends approval of the Edsall Substation

The revised site plan for the proposed Edsall Substation moves it next to the Ridges of Edsall townhomes. The transmission line would be over the Turkeycock Run Resource Protection Area. [Fairfax County staff report]

A report by Fairfax County planning and zoning staff recommends the Planning Commission approve Dominion Energy’s proposal for a 34-acre substation to serve a data center at the Plaza 500 site on Edsall Road.

The Planning Commission is holding a public hearing on the substation on Dec. 2.

According to the staff report, “the general or approximate location, character, and extent of Dominion’s proposed substation on the subject property is substantially in accord with the adopted Comprehensive Plan. Therefore, staff recommends that the Planning Commission find 2232-2025-MA-00007 to be substantially in accord with the Comprehensive Plan, subject to the enhanced screening, landscaping, setback, architectural wall, and other design commitments to mitigate impacts to adjacent properties proposed in Dominion’s most recent application submission.”

Related story: Residents urged to come out in force for the hearing on the Edsall substation

Tyler Ray, the founder of the Save Bren Mar Coalition, a grassroots group that has been fighting against the data center and the substation for years, says the report has significant factual errors, including the distance between the substation and residences, the height of the proposed structure, and conflicts with the Comprehensive Plan. Ray’s analysis of the report is summarized below.

A massive data center and substation doesn’t belong next to homes in Bren Mar Park or anywhere else in Mason District, Ray said. If this project is approved, it will set a dangerous precedent for the rest of Fairfax County.

“Neighbors will pack the room on Dec. 2 to make sure this doesn’t go through,” he said. Sign up to speak at the hearing here. The Planning Commission meeting starts at 7:30 p.m. at the Fairfax County Government Center, 12000 Government Center Parkway in Fairfax.

The Mason District Land Use Committee will vote on whether to recommend approval of the substation on Nov. 30. The MDLUC meeting will be held at Belvedere Elementary School at 7:30 p.m.

Related story: Community members speak out against a substation at Plaza 500

Action by the Planning Commission will determine the fate of the data center project. Because the substation is a public facility, it goes through a 2232 process, which means the Board of Supervisors won’t hold a hearing or vote on the substation.

The data center, to be constructed by Starwood Capital, is a by-right project, which means it doesn’t need to go through a hearing process or approval by the Board of Supervisors. The State Corporation Commission has already approved a high-voltage transmission line for a future substation.

Dominion has revised an earlier site plan, so now the substation would be adjacent to the Ridges of Edsall townhomes.

The proposed Edsall substation would provide 176 megawatts of projected load to serve the data center. It would operate at 230/34.5 kV, supplying voltage transformation between the transmission and distribution systems. The associated overhead transmission lines would connect the substation to the existing Hayfield-Van Dorn and Ox-Van Dorn transmission lines at the Van Dorn substation.

Tyler Ray speaks at a rally against the substation earlier this month on Edsall Road.

Improper and incomplete analysis

In addition to the numerous factual errors, Ray said, the staff report on the substation offers “an incomplete presentation of the Comprehensive Plan and State Corporation Commission record, and an improper reliance on the Zoning Ordinance in reviewing a public facility for compliance with the Comprehensive Plan” under the 2232 review process required by the Virginia Code.

“Collectively, these legal, analytical, and factual errors undermine the core rationale and staff analysis used to reach a recommendation of substantial accord,” he said.

According to Ray, the staff report also:

  • Misstates SCC authority, overstates SCC approval scope, improperly adopts cost-driven utility rejections, and allows developer-imposed site constraints to dictate Comprehensive Plan evaluation.
  • Omits consideration of planned residential development in the City of Alexandria and fails to evaluate compatibility with surrounding residential transitions.
  • Relies on incorrect GIS measurements, omitting 98-99-foot backbone structure and transmission pole heights from the SCC record and relies on visual screening rendered ineffective by topography and transmission clear-cutting.
  • Misrepresents Dominion’s definitions to present dedicated data center capacity as general “surrounding area” grid enhancement.
  • Ignores the environmental impacts of routing associated transmission lines through a Resource Protection Area necessitated by the proposed substation location.

Improper legal standard

“In analyzing the existing site conditions and surrounding area, county staff incorrectly conflate the legal standards for zoning review with those governing public facility review,” Ray said.

Under the Virginia Code section on 2232 reviews, the Planning Commission must determine whether the location, character, and extent of a proposed public facility are in substantial accord with the Comprehensive Plan.

The substation is a public facility that is not a “feature shown” on the county’s adopted plan. Consequently, whether the facility is permitted by right or by special exception under the Zoning Ordinance – or whether it complies with specific standards of the Substation Zoning Ordinance amendment adopted in December 2025 – is a legally irrelevant 2232 determination. 

Related story: Planning Commission defers hearing on substation to Dec. 2

As documented in legal correspondence submitted to county staff by the Alliance Law Group, zoning compliance is a separate inquiry and does not provide legal justification for finding substantial accord with the Comprehensive Plan.

Furthermore, Ray noted, the staff report identifies the property’s zoning district as I-3 and I-5, implying a heavier industrial context for the project. However, the substation pad is located wholly within the I-3 (light intensity industrial) portion of the site.

“Any inference that the substation is situated in a heavier industrial location through reference to the I-5 district as justification for being in substantial accord is factually inaccurate,” he said.

Misrepresentation of project need

Throughout the staff report, Ray said, “staff repeatedly interpret Dominion Energy’s statements regarding supporting ‘anticipated electricity demands in the surrounding area’ and ‘additional electrical grid demand’ as evidence that the substation will serve future non-data-center residential or commercial growth in the community. This interpretation misconstrues standard utility terminology.”

In county and SCC filings, Dominion classifies contracted data center capacity as existing regional demand within the surrounding area, making no distinction between the data center and residential or commercial customers.

Read in proper context, he said, references to “anticipated electricity demands” and “supporting electrical grid demand” refer to the initial energization load of the data center and its subsequent multiphase operational expansion.

The staff report’s discussion of facility expansion confirms that the substation is sized specifically to accommodate data center load growth, Ray said. Additionally, the size at full build-out must also be considered as part of a 2232 analysis. 

Renderings of the substation in the 2232 application show no distribution connections to any customer other than the data center.

Misstated SCC authority

According to Ray, the staff report incorrectly asserts that the SCC established the approved project configuration, including the substation location, and thus requires construction at a specific location on the subject property.

In its Aug. 8, 2025, final order (Case No. PUR-2024-00135), the SCC evaluated and approved only the 230 kV transmission lines, not the substation site under a Comprehensive Plan review. 

Fairfax County reserved its right to not make a recommendation on the substation during the SCC proceeding.

Related story: State agency approves transmission line in Bren Mar Park

Regarding substation alternative sites, staff acknowledged that the Van Dorn Substation represents the only other evaluated site, and that it is a viable alternative.

The staff report says “there appear to be limited viable alternative locations.” Staff adopted the SCC’s cost-driven rejection of Van Dorn “without performing an independent Comprehensive Plan evaluation.”

“Critically,” Ray said, “co-locating facilities at Van Dorn would remove heavy electrical infrastructure from proximity to 28,000 residents within a one-mile radius and eliminate 0.9 miles of new overhead transmission lines adjacent to homes, through a property seeking mixed-use redevelopment, and across a Resource Protection Area.” 

Incompatible land use

The staff report presents an incomplete baseline of surrounding land uses. It says properties to the east in the City of Alexandria are zoned industrial and are developed with warehouses and the Alexandria Waste Recovery facility.

While that describes present conditions, the report fails to mention that Alexandria’s adopted Comprehensive Plan designates that area for residential redevelopment, including the planned removal of the waste recovery facility. 

Additionally, an approved mixed-use redevelopment at the former Vulcan site, located approximately 800 feet from Plaza 500, is currently under active construction. 

To the south, during SCC proceedings, the adjacent property owner testified in opposition to the transmission line route because the overhead lines directly impair their planned mixed-use development.

Related story: Residents urge Virginia to impose a data center moratorium

Staff’s reliance on historical industrial development to justify substantial accord ignores the evolving land-use pattern established by the Comprehensive Plan.

The Lincolnia Planning District Plan explicitly states that stable residential areas must be preserved and specifies that “infill development must match the character, intensity, and density of existing residential uses.”

Introducing a huge industrial utility substation onto an isolated I-3 parcel enclosed by existing and planned residential communities conflicts directly with these policy guidance goals.

Flawed setbacks

The staff report states that “the applicant has not provided information regarding the height of the major electrical equipment, including backbone structures and static poles, within the proposed substation,” relying instead on generic assumptions (23 to 28-foot transformers, 75-foot static poles, and 75 to 95-foot structures).

However, the SCC evidentiary record – which staff cites extensively elsewhere – explicitly provides these maximum structural heights: transformers at 31 feet, static poles at 98 feet, and backbone terminal structures at 99 feet. This data was also previously submitted to staff by local residents.

Staff relies on the applicant’s figures asserting a 124-foot setback from the northwestern corner of the substation to the nearest residential property line at the Ridges at Edsall. Official county GIS mapping demonstrates that this measurement is incorrect. The applicant measured to an internal residential fence line rather than the actual property boundary. 

The true distance to the property line is 108 feet (16 feet closer), and the applicant improperly claimed credit for 16 feet of off-site vegetative buffer over which it exercises no property control.

Substation opponents packed the room at a Mason District Land Use Committee meeting in July.

The applicant’s revised site layout shifts the perimeter fence and lower-profile transformers eastward (resulting in more homes with a view of the transformers than the original location) while retaining the 99-foot backbone structures near residential properties.

A 15-foot precast architectural wall fails to mitigate the visual impact of 98 to 99-foot steel structures, particularly given topographically elevated residential vantage points looking down into the site. 

Furthermore, supplemental tree plantings shown in illustrations in the staff report are oriented toward Edsall Road rather than residential lines of sight, and the diagrams omit the 100-foot cleared right-of-way required for incoming transmission lines.

Near the Bren Pointe and Isabella communities, vegetation within the transmission corridor will be clear-cut or restricted to growth under three feet in height, eliminating existing visual buffering.

Siloed environmental review

While the physical substation pad sits outside mapped environmental quality corridors, floodplains, and Resource Protection Areas (RPAs), siting the facility at this location under the restrictions put in place by the data center developer necessitates routing high-voltage transmission lines directly through an established RPA along Turkeycock Run and Backlick Run and parallel to the Bren Pointe and Isabella communities.

Staff maintains that under state and county codes, the electric transmission lines authorized by the SCC are compliant with the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Ordinance.

However, a statutory exemption from local environmental permitting does not relieve the county of its obligation under the 2232 review requirements to evaluate environmental impacts when determining whether a facility’s location is in substantial accord with the Comprehensive Plan.

Siting the substation on the subject parcel forces environmental degradation within the RPA corridor that would be entirely avoided by co-locating the infrastructure at the Van Dorn Substation.

Related story: State agency approves transmission line in Bren Mar Park

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *